Skip to main content
Penalty Relief Does Not Resolve the Whole IRS Balance: Use a Two-Track Response

Penalty Relief Does Not Resolve the Whole IRS Balance: Use a Two-Track Response

Fusion Legal & Tax · November 16, 2026Practice Area7 min readPenalty Abatement

Opening an IRS notice can make the entire balance feel like one immovable number. It usually helps to separate the problem into two tracks:

  1. Can the penalty be removed or reduced?
  2. What must happen with the underlying return, tax, and interest?

That distinction matters because penalty relief can be meaningful without resolving everything on the notice. In its July 8, 2026 announcement of the Automatic Exemption from Penalty program, the IRS stated: “While AEP prevents the assessment of certain penalties, taxpayers must still pay any tax and interest due, as well as any penalties not eligible for relief.”

In other words, a successful penalty-relief review may lower the balance—but it is not necessarily the end of the matter. A protective response addresses the penalty and the remaining account issue at the same time.

First, break the notice into separate parts

Before calling the IRS or sending a written explanation, identify what the notice actually says. Look for:

  • the taxpayer name and identification number;
  • the tax form and tax period involved;
  • whether the IRS says a return, payment, or deposit was late;
  • the type and amount of each penalty;
  • the underlying tax shown as due;
  • interest assessed through the notice date;
  • payments or credits already applied; and
  • the response date and contact instructions printed on the notice.

Do not assume every line represents a penalty. Likewise, do not assume that removing one penalty will remove another charge. The IRS’s administrative penalty-relief guidance identifies failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, and failure-to-deposit penalties as penalties eligible for relief under First Time Abate or the new Automatic Exemption from Penalty. Other assessments may require a different analysis.

A simple worksheet can make the account easier to understand:

Notice itemAmountQuestion to answer
Underlying tax$___Is the return or adjustment accurate?
Interest$___What period does it cover?
Failure-to-file penalty$___Could administrative or reasonable-cause relief apply?
Failure-to-pay penalty$___Could administrative or reasonable-cause relief apply?
Other penalty$___What authority and relief process does the notice identify?
Payments and credits($___)Were all payments posted to the correct period?

This is not busywork. It prevents a conversation about penalty relief from obscuring a missing payment, an unfiled return, or a disagreement about the underlying tax.

Track one: determine whether the penalty qualifies for relief

There is more than one path to IRS penalty relief. Which path applies depends on the return, tax period, penalty, filing history, payment history, and surrounding facts.

Automatic Exemption from Penalty

As announced in July 2026, the IRS is transitioning from First Time Abate to a new Automatic Exemption from Penalty, or AEP. The IRS says AEP applies to eligible original returns beginning with tax year 2025 and 2026 quarterly returns, as well as future tax periods.

The load-bearing eligibility rule is stated in the IRS announcement: taxpayers qualify if they have “a history of timely filing the return and paying any tax due in the three prior years (or 12 consecutive quarters for quarterly returns).” If eligible, the taxpayer does not need to request relief; the IRS says it will apply AEP and issue a notice confirming that relief was granted.

Not every filing qualifies. The IRS says that information returns and returns filed only for specific transactions or infrequent events—such as Forms 706 and 709—generally are not eligible. AEP also does not erase unpaid tax, interest, or penalties outside the program.

First Time Abate during the transition

The IRS is phasing out the longstanding First Time Abate process as it transitions to AEP. According to the IRS’s detailed comparison of administrative relief, First Time Abate has required taxpayers to contact the IRS, although they do not need to use the phrase “First Time Abate” or provide supporting documents with the request. The IRS reviews its account information to determine whether the requirements are met.

The July 2026 announcement warns that some qualifying taxpayers may still receive penalty notices during the transition. Taxpayers who believe they qualify may contact the IRS to request First Time Abate. AEP is expected to replace it for eligible returns with original due dates on or after January 1, 2027.

That makes the tax period and original due date important. A taxpayer should not assume that a newly issued notice necessarily falls under the new automatic process.

Reasonable-cause relief

A taxpayer who does not qualify for AEP may still be able to request relief based on reasonable cause. The IRS says it will review those requests and notify taxpayers of the outcome.

Reasonable cause is not simply a request for sympathy, and relief is not automatic. A useful submission should connect the relevant events to the specific filing, payment, or deposit failure and include records that support the timeline. Depending on the circumstances, that might mean organizing correspondence, payment confirmations, filing records, or documents showing when an event began and ended.

The goal is a clear factual explanation—not a longer story than the records can support.

Track two: address the tax, interest, and filing problem

Penalty relief should not become a reason to leave the rest of the account untouched. The IRS advises taxpayers not to wait to respond because “fees, penalties and interest accumulate,” and a failure to respond can lead to more serious collection activity, including liens or levies. The agency’s December 2023 explanation of penalty relief and payment options also encourages taxpayers who owe tax or have overdue returns to review payment options and file outstanding returns.

A two-track response may therefore include:

  • confirming whether the underlying return was filed and processed;
  • comparing the notice against proof of filing and payment;
  • checking whether a payment was applied to the wrong tax period or account;
  • filing an outstanding return even if full payment is not presently possible;
  • evaluating the payment options identified by the IRS; and
  • requesting applicable penalty relief without treating that request as a substitute for resolving the remaining balance.

If the underlying tax is disputed, the response may need to focus first on how the IRS calculated it and what procedural rights the notice provides. If the tax is accurate but cannot be paid in full, the immediate question becomes how to keep the matter moving toward a workable resolution.

What if the IRS already applied automatic relief?

The IRS says AEP is applied when an eligible original return completes processing. A qualifying taxpayer should receive a letter explaining that the applicable penalties were not assessed because of the taxpayer’s history of timely compliance.

If that letter arrives, compare it with the account balance rather than assuming the account is finished. Confirm:

  • which penalty was not assessed;
  • which tax period received relief;
  • whether another penalty remains;
  • how much tax and interest is still due; and
  • whether a separate filing or payment issue still needs attention.

If a notice instead shows an assessed penalty and the taxpayer believes AEP should have applied, the IRS’s administrative relief page directs the taxpayer to contact the agency. Keep the notice, the return, proof of payment, and records for the prior compliance years together before making that contact.

A practical response checklist

When a penalty notice arrives, consider this sequence:

  1. Confirm the notice is authentic using contact information from an independently accessed IRS channel.
  2. Calendar the response date shown on the notice.
  3. Separate tax, interest, and each penalty into distinct line items.
  4. Confirm the return and payment history for the notice period and the relevant prior years.
  5. Check whether AEP was already applied or whether a transition-period First Time Abate request may be appropriate.
  6. Evaluate reasonable cause separately if administrative relief does not apply.
  7. Collect records before responding, including the notice, return, account transcript if available, payment proof, and timeline documents.
  8. Address outstanding returns and the remaining balance rather than waiting for the penalty decision to solve everything.
  9. Keep copies and contact notes, including dates, names or identification numbers, and any response deadlines provided.
  10. Review the next IRS letter carefully to confirm what was—and was not—changed.

The right question is not only “Can this penalty go away?”

A better question is: What combination of penalty review, account correction, filing work, and payment planning will move this matter toward resolution?

That wider view protects against two common mistakes: paying an incorrect notice without reviewing it, or pursuing penalty relief while the underlying tax problem continues to grow.

Fusion Legal & Tax helps individuals and businesses understand IRS notices, organize the account history, evaluate available penalty-relief paths, and address the balance that may remain. Outcomes depend on the taxpayer’s records, compliance history, type of penalty, tax period, and the IRS’s review. This article provides general educational information and is not legal or tax advice for any particular situation.

Have Questions?
Chat with Margot